The first invitation came in early October, which tells you something about my friends. They plan and are generous enough to include me. One friend texted to say that since the girls wouldn’t be with me this year, I was welcome to join their family for Thanksgiving dinner, and since she loves to cook, I need only bring myself. The second came a week later when a friend invited me to join her family as they dress up like poultry and run the annual pre-Thanksgiving Turkey Trot in our town. The third invitation came from a new acquaintance who invited me to stop by for dessert and a few hours watching Thanksgiving Day football.
Here is my situation. One of my daughters is traveling to be with her fiancé’s family, and the other is spending the holiday with her dad. That is how it works when real life enters the Thanksgiving chat. Still, it means that nobody needs me to orchestrate the annual feast. I have a free Thursday in late November, several generous invitations, and a decision to make about how I want to spend the day, alone or with someone else’s family.
Stacking the Day
The ambitious option is to say yes to everyone. Turkey Trot in the morning, an early dinner at one house and dessert/football at another. I’m already thinking about the outfit changes required for the day; workout clothes in the morning, festive holiday attire at mid-day, and team spirit gear in the evening. And let’s not forget the hostess gifts and bread-and-butter notes. With all of that required for one day, I’m certain to spend Black Friday on the couch recovering.
It’s truly lovely being welcomed into my friends’ holiday traditions. It tells me the friendships I’ve built over the years are real, and that people noticed I’d be on my own and did something about it. There is also something a little strange about arriving at another family’s holiday. Everyone would be kind, and I’d be glad to be there, but being an audience to someone else’s traditions would also make me a little sad to not be experiencing my own with my family.
The Case for Tomato Soup
Then there’s another option, which has been sitting in the back of my mind for several weeks. I could stay home and enjoy a cup of tomato soup, a grilled cheese made with good bread and too much butter, and a movie marathon that starts in the early afternoon and ends whenever I fall asleep. Love Actually and The Holiday are at the top of my holiday favorites list and are the perfect way to kick-off the season while still getting to wear my coziest pajamas.
The appeal is obvious. No driving across town, no having to eat someone’s “family favorite” that could be an acquired taste, no wondering whether it’s rude to leave at halftime when your team is losing. After decades of making the holiday happen for others, there’s real freedom in letting it happen without me.
But I’m honest enough to admit I don’t know how I’d feel by evening. Staying home might feel delicious at two in the afternoon and a little lonely by six, when I start picturing everyone else around a table. Or it might not. I can imagine both versions of that afternoon equally well, which is probably why I haven’t answered anyone yet.
When the Table Changes Shape
What I keep coming back to is that the holiday didn’t change because I stopped loving it. It changed because the people around the table grew up and the family reorganized itself, the way families do. My daughters are building their own versions of Thanksgiving now, with partners and in-laws and their own opinions that don’t include Grandma’s stuffing recipe. Their dad gets his turn. All of that is fair and right, but I’d be fibbing if I said it didn’t leave a gap in November.
I suspect plenty of women reading this are looking at a similar calendar. Maybe the kids are with the in-laws this year, or the house that always hosted has been sold, or the person who carved the turkey isn’t here anymore. The holiday we spent decades enjoying has changed shape, and we’re still figuring out how to do a new version.
Regrets Only
In the end, I RSVP’d no to the Turkey Trot because I hate running (no-brainer here), although the costume part would have been fun. I graciously declined the family dinner and am planning for tomato soup and an extra-gooey grilled cheese.
As for the dessert/football invitation, I opted to stay home and start early on my tradition of baking loaves of pumpkin bread I’ll deliver to friends and family. This way I get a head start on holiday baking and still have energy to venture out and hit the Black Friday sales.
So that’s my Thanksgiving this year: a bowl of soup, a stack of RSVPs sent on time, and a kitchen that smells like cinnamon and nutmeg by Wednesday night. I’ll miss my girls, and I suspect I’ll text them more than they’d like. Still, I’m curious to see what the holiday feels like when I’m the one deciding its shape, and if six o’clock does get a little lonely, Hugh Grant will be dancing through 10 Downing Street right on schedule.
Let’s Chat:
How are you spending Thanksgiving this year? Have you been invited to share a friend’s holiday dinner? What do you miss most about holidays past?



